Should I Settle My Injury Claim or Go to Trial?

If you’ve been injured in an accident—whether it was a car crash, a slip and fall at a business, or a workplace injury—you're likely facing more than just physical pain. You might be dealing with mounting medical bills, lost wages, emotional stress, and an overwhelming number of decisions about your legal rights. One of the most common and important questions injury victims face is this: Should I settle my claim or take it to trial?

A personal injury claim in California is a legal process that allows an injured person to seek compensation from the party responsible for causing their injury—typically due to negligence, recklessness, or intentional misconduct. The goal of a personal injury claim is to make the injured person “whole” again by covering the financial and emotional losses resulting from the incident.

That’s why it’s so important to fully understand both settlement and trial options before making any decisions. These paths come with very different risks, timelines, and outcomes. What’s right for one case might not be right for another, and rushing into a settlement—or dragging out a trial—without the right guidance can be costly.

What Does It Mean to Settle a Case?

When you hear that someone “settled” their personal injury case, it means they reached a legal agreement to resolve the claim outside of court. Instead of taking the case to trial, the injured party (plaintiff) and the at-fault party (typically through their insurance company) agree on a compensation amount to end the dispute.

The timeline for receiving a settlement offer varies, but most offers occur after medical treatment is complete or a full assessment of the injuries is available. Some insurance companies may make a quick offer within weeks of the accident—often before the full extent of your injuries is even known. Others may delay until after you’ve submitted a formal demand letter and completed negotiations.

Typical Settlement Process

1. Demand Letter
   Your attorney will send a detailed letter to the insurance company outlining your injuries, medical treatment, lost wages, and other damages, along with a request for a specific settlement amount.
2. Negotiations with the Insurance Company
   After receiving the demand letter, the insurance adjuster will likely respond with a lower counteroffer. This begins a back-and-forth negotiation process. Your attorney’s role is to advocate for a fair settlement based on the full value of your claim.
3. Agreement Terms
   If both parties agree on a number, the settlement is put in writing. You’ll typically sign a release of liability, agreeing not to pursue any further legal action in exchange for the agreed compensation.

Pros of Settling Your Injury Claim

• Faster Resolution – Settlements can conclude in weeks or months, whereas trials may take a year or more.
• Less Expensive – Avoids court costs, expert witness fees, and other trial-related expenses.
• Less Stressful – No need to testify in court or relive the trauma of the accident.
• Guaranteed Compensation – Once a settlement is signed, the payment is binding and typically issued shortly after.

Cons of Settling Your Injury Claim

• Possibly Lower Compensation – Settlements may offer less than what a jury could award in court, especially in high-damage cases.
• No Public Record of Liability – The responsible party may not be held publicly accountable in the way a trial verdict would.
• No Opportunity to Appeal – Once you accept a settlement, you cannot go back and ask for more money—even if your injuries worsen later.

What Does It Mean to Go to Trial?

While many personal injury claims are resolved through settlement, some cases need to be taken to court to achieve fair compensation. Going to trial means your case is presented before a judge or jury, who will determine whether the defendant is liable and how much you should be awarded in damages.

Trial Process in California

1. Filing a Lawsuit
   If settlement negotiations break down, your attorney may file a formal complaint in civil court. This begins the litigation process and officially names the parties involved.
2. Discovery Phase
   Both sides exchange information, documents, and evidence. This may include medical records, accident reports, surveillance footage, depositions, and expert witness evaluations. Discovery can last several months and is a critical step in building your case.
3. Mediation or Settlement Conferences
   Even after a lawsuit is filed, courts often encourage parties to resolve disputes before trial through mediation or mandatory settlement conferences. These sessions involve a neutral third party who helps both sides try to reach a resolution.
4. Trial Before a Judge or Jury
   If mediation fails, the case proceeds to trial. Each side presents evidence and arguments. A judge or jury will then decide if the defendant is liable and, if so, how much compensation is owed.

Pros of Going to Trial

• Potential for Higher Compensation – Juries may award more in damages than what the insurance company is willing to offer in a settlement, especially in cases involving serious or permanent injuries.
• Opportunity to Hold the Wrongdoer Publicly Accountable – A trial puts the facts on record, which can help prevent future harm and serve as a form of justice for the injured party.
• Appeals Process Available – If there are legal errors during the trial, the decision may be appealed, offering a potential path to a better outcome.

Cons of Going to Trial

• Time-Consuming – Personal injury trials in California can take a year or more to conclude, depending on the court calendar and complexity of the case.
• Costly – Trials often require expert witnesses, depositions, exhibit preparation, and court fees. While many attorneys work on contingency, these costs can impact the net recovery.
• Uncertainty of Outcome – Juries can be unpredictable. Even strong cases can be lost, and favorable verdicts may still be subject to appeals or reduced awards.

Key Factors in Deciding Whether to Settle or Go to Trial

Severity of Injuries and Damages

The more serious your injuries, the more likely it is that your case may need to go to trial—especially if the insurance company refuses to offer a settlement that covers long-term care, future surgeries, or permanent disability. Minor injuries are often resolved through settlement, but catastrophic injuries may require a jury to fully appreciate their life-changing impact.

Strength of Evidence

Cases with clear evidence of fault and well-documented damages are more likely to settle favorably. But if evidence is weak or conflicting, or if the insurance company believes it has a chance of winning at trial, they may refuse a fair settlement. Your attorney will help assess how strong your case is—from medical records and witness statements to accident reports and expert testimony.

Liability Disputes

If the other party denies fault—or tries to blame you—this can make settling more difficult. In California, comparative negligence laws allow compensation to be reduced if you're partially at fault. In these cases, a trial may be necessary to clarify liability and assign fault appropriately.

Insurance Policy Limits

Even if your damages are substantial, the insurance policy limits may cap how much compensation you can receive through settlement. If the responsible party is underinsured, going to trial may help identify other liable parties or explore additional sources of recovery.

Client’s Risk Tolerance

Some clients are comfortable taking a case to court, while others prefer a quicker, guaranteed resolution—even if it means accepting less. Your personal comfort with risk, timelines, and uncertainty plays a big role in this decision. A good attorney won’t pressure you either way—they’ll help you understand the risks and benefits so you can make the decision that feels right for you.

Long-Term Impact of the Injury

If your injury involves ongoing medical care, future surgeries, or a loss of earning capacity, it's crucial to ensure any settlement reflects those long-term needs. Trials offer an opportunity to present expert medical and financial testimony that can increase the value of your case. A settlement that doesn’t account for future costs could leave you paying out of pocket down the road.

Which Path Is Right for You?

When it comes to choosing between settling your personal injury claim or going to trial, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Every case is different—shaped by the details of your injury, the strength of the evidence, the attitude of the insurance company, and your personal goals for recovery and justice.

What’s most important is that you make this decision with the right information and trusted legal guidance. You need an attorney who not only understands the law but who also listens to your concerns, respects your values, and develops a strategy tailored to your unique situation.

At Tim D. Wright Law, we never push clients toward one option or the other. Instead, we provide honest legal advice backed by experience—so you can choose the path that’s best for your health, your finances, and your future.

Get Legal Advice Before You Decide

📍 Burbank Office
1112 W. Burbank Blvd., Suite 302, Burbank, CA 91506
📞 (323) 379-9995

📍 Van Nuys Workers’ Comp Office
16555 Sherman Way, Suite B2, Van Nuys, CA 91406
📞 (818) 428-1080

📧 Email: firm@timwrightlaw.com
🌐 Website: www.timwrightlaw.com

👉 Follow us for legal tips and updates:
Facebook | Instagram | Twitter

‍