.png)
If you’ve been injured in an accident—whether it was a car crash, a slip and fall, or another form of negligence—you may be asking one of the most important legal questions: Should I settle my personal injury case or take it to trial?
The truth is, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. While most personal injury cases in California settle out of court, there are situations where taking your case before a judge or jury may be the only way to get fair compensation. Choosing the right path requires a clear understanding of your injuries, the strength of your evidence, the insurance company’s position, and your personal goals for recovery.
At Tim D. Wright Law, we’re here to guide you every step of the way. With deep experience handling personal injury claims across Southern California, we help clients weigh their options carefully and make informed choices that protect both their health and their future.
In legal terms, a settlement is a mutual agreement between the injured party (the plaintiff) and the responsible party (usually through their insurance company) to resolve the claim outside of court. Instead of going through a full trial, both sides agree on a compensation amount that the injured person will accept in exchange for dropping the lawsuit or not filing one at all.
In most cases, the settlement process involves negotiation between your personal injury attorney and the insurance company. The insurer may make an initial offer, and your attorney will work to negotiate a better amount based on your medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages.
Once a settlement is reached and both sides sign an agreement, the case is officially closed. Importantly, by signing the agreement, you are typically waiving your right to pursue further legal action against the at-fault party for this incident—even if your condition worsens later.
One of the key things to know is that a personal injury case can be settled at almost any stage, including:
Settlements usually resolve much more quickly than trials. Rather than waiting months—or even years—for a court date, you can receive compensation in weeks or a few short months, depending on the case.
Settling often means lower overall expenses. Trials involve court fees, expert witnesses, extensive attorney hours, and other litigation costs. By settling early, you reduce these financial burdens.
When you agree to a settlement, you know exactly how much you’ll receive. In contrast, trial outcomes can be unpredictable, with the risk of receiving less—or nothing at all.
Most settlements are confidential, which means the details of your case stay private. If you go to trial, court records and proceedings are generally public.
Avoiding court also means avoiding the stress of testifying, being cross-examined, or reliving the accident. For many clients, this peace of mind is reason enough to settle.
A jury might award significantly more than what the insurance company is offering in a settlement—especially if there are aggravating factors like gross negligence or permanent disability.
Settlements are typically made “without admission of liability,” which means the at-fault party doesn’t have to take responsibility for what happened—even if it’s clear they were negligent.
Once you accept a settlement, it’s final. If your medical condition worsens or new expenses arise, you cannot go back and ask for more compensation later.
Insurance companies are businesses. They often offer early settlements in hopes of resolving the case before the full extent of your injuries is known. Accepting too soon could mean leaving significant money on the table.
While most personal injury cases are resolved through settlement, some claims reach a point where going to trial becomes necessary. This usually happens when the insurance company refuses to offer fair compensation, denies responsibility, or disputes the seriousness of your injuries.
Going to trial means that your case will be presented in court, where a judge or jury will evaluate the evidence and decide two key questions:
This process is known as litigation, and it involves several formal legal steps:
A trial can either be a bench trial, where a judge makes the final decision, or a jury trial, where a group of your peers listens to the case and renders a verdict.
One of the biggest reasons plaintiffs go to trial is the potential to recover more than what’s offered in settlement. Juries can award damages for:
If your injuries are severe and long-lasting, a trial verdict could far exceed a pre-trial settlement.
Trials hold negligent parties publicly accountable. A verdict sends a clear message that their actions—or lack of safety measures—caused real harm. For many victims, this sense of justice is just as important as financial compensation.
The courtroom gives you the chance to share your experience directly, in your own words. This human element can resonate with a jury and lead to a more favorable outcome.
In rare but powerful instances, trial verdicts can set legal precedent or influence industry policies, encouraging companies or institutions to improve safety practices or procedures.
A personal injury trial can take months or even years, especially if the court system is backlogged or the case is complex. This means longer delays in receiving compensation, which can create financial stress during recovery.
Trials are expensive. Between expert witnesses, court filings, pre-trial motions, and the time required from your legal team, litigation costs can add up quickly. While many attorneys (including Tim D. Wright Law) work on a contingency fee basis, those costs are still deducted from your final award.
Unlike a settlement, trial outcomes are unpredictable. A jury may side with the defendant, award less than expected, or be influenced by factors outside of your control. Even a strong case can result in a disappointing verdict.
Reliving the trauma of your injury, undergoing cross-examination, and enduring the stress of a public legal battle can be mentally and emotionally exhausting. For some clients, this burden outweighs the potential financial reward.
Deciding whether to settle your personal injury case or take it to trial isn’t just a legal choice—it’s a personal one that can shape your financial future, your recovery process, and your peace of mind. With so much on the line, it’s not a decision you should make alone.
Every personal injury case is different. The right path for one client may be completely wrong for another. It depends on the severity of your injuries, the strength of your evidence, the willingness of the insurance company to negotiate, and your long-term needs.
At Tim D. Wright Law, we help injury victims throughout Burbank, Van Nuys, and Southern California make smart, informed decisions at every stage of their case. We’ll evaluate your options honestly, explain the risks and rewards of settlement versus trial, and fight to get you the maximum compensation you’re entitled to—whether that happens across a negotiation table or in front of a jury.
📍 Burbank Office – Personal Injury Cases
1112 W. Burbank Blvd., Suite 302
Burbank, CA 91506
📞 Phone: (323) 379-9995
📧 Email: firm@timwrightlaw.com
🌐 Website: www.timwrightlaw.com
Facebook | Instagram | Twitter
